It's MLB Trading season, and to prepare, Alex Speier over at EEI has a solid breakdown of the Sox prospects that would be brought up in any trade discussions. Speier approaches it not from a Sox perspective, but what perceived value the prospects have to other squads. He breaks the prospects down into 4 tiers:
Top Tier: Will MIddlebrooks and Anthony Ranaudo
Tweeners: Ryan Kalish, Josh Reddick and Jose Iglesias
Second Tier: Bryce Brentz, Brandon Jacobs, Felix Doubront, Ryan Lavarnway, Kyle Weiland, Chih-Hsieh Chiang, Xander Bogaerts, Yamaico Navarro, Sean Coyle and Alex Wilson
Noteworthy: Drake Britton, Stolmy Pimentel, Lars Anderson, Garin Cecchini and Stephen Fife
The biggest takeaway from this list is the fact that we have a guy in our system named "Xander Bogaerts"! How did I now know this? Why is that not common knowledge? Why doesn't Xander have his own TV show? Apparently I need to play closer attention to Greenville.
Shocking how far Lars Anderson has fallen. Not sure what you do with him at this point. He has no real future with the Sox, and that clearly plays a role in how much you can get for him in a swap. The Sox only course with him is to either dump him for whatever they can get (or use him as a throw-in), or let him stew in the minors for a few seasons and hope he develops some value. Not great.
I also think that Reddick has done enough at the Major League level to vault himself into the top-tier, but I doubt (read: desperately hope) that Theo would even entertain moving him. We still have that hole in RF to fill in 2012.
For Iglesias, not surprisingly, his bat is what's keeping him from the top tier.
“No matter how good his glove is he has to hit some, doesn’t he?” mused one evalutor.
However, anoter evaluator insists that Iglesias’ swing will ensure that he can improve, since he shows the hand-eye coordination to make consistent contact. That evaluator noted that it would be premature to dismiss a player’s offensive potential based on his struggles as a 21-year-old, and suggested that while he has dipped from his position as a top chip, he would still represent a tweener.
“I think his value is still high, even though he hasn’t put up the offensive numbers you like to see,” said the evaluator. “His defense is off the charts. … And I think his bat will get better as he gets older and has more plate appearances.”
Don't let all that negative talk fool you, though. There's not a team out there that wouldn't love to have Iglesias in their system.
But it's 22 year old Will MIddlebrooks that's seen as the star of our system. So much so, that Speier even mentions putting him at 3rd over Youk. Gasp!
Middlebrooks is viewed as a future power hitting third baseman who will offer an impressive, well-rounded package of above-average offense and defense. He will be the first player about whom most teams will ask in trade conversations. That said, his value to the Sox is also substantial, given that he is expected to be big league-ready by the time that Kevin Youkilis’ contract expires. If Youkilis either departs or were to transition to DH, Middlebrooks is situated as his logical successor at third.
There's a solid breakdown of virtually every player listed above. It's well worth the read. Won't do anything to help you beat the heat, but let's be honest with eachother; You were just going to waste the rest of your Thursday afternoon anyway.
Here's to hoping we don't see Beltran in a Sox uniform in 2 weeks.